All people, messages, amounts and replies in these examples are fictional. Adapt the wording to your situation; no script guarantees a response.

Before you begin

Choose something recent enough that the other person can remember it: a presentation, a handover or a client conversation. Say whether you want feedback on the result, your process or how you communicated. These are different questions.

Ask someone who actually observed the work. Give them a little time and explain how you will use the answer. You do not have to agree with every interpretation, but deciding immediately that the feedback is wrong can cut off information you asked to hear.

What to say: example wording

Ask after a presentation

“Could you give me some feedback on the first five minutes of today’s presentation? I was trying to make the decision clear. Where did I give too much or too little context?”

Noor keeps the scope small. The question can be answered without reviewing every aspect of their performance.

Request an example

“You mentioned I could be more concise. Is there one moment you could point to where you wanted me to get to the point sooner? What did you need to hear instead?”

A concrete instance makes an abstract comment usable. Ask with curiosity rather than the tone of a cross-examination.

Arrange a follow-up

“For next week’s update I’m going to lead with the decision and put the background at the end. Could you tell me afterward if that was easier to follow?”

This is a small experiment with a clear observation, not a promise to transform your whole communication style overnight.

What not to say, and why

  • “Was I good?” It invites reassurance without showing what you want to learn.
  • “Be brutally honest.” You can request directness without inviting cruelty: “Please be specific, including what did not work.”
  • “But you don’t understand…” before they finish. Write down the point, clarify it, then add relevant context.

How the other person might react

These are invented possibilities to prepare for, not predictions.

They say everything was fine

“I’m glad the overall result worked. Was there one part you would shorten or explain differently next time?” If they still have nothing to add, accept that they may not have useful detail.

The feedback feels unfair

“My understanding was that the audience needed that background. What were you seeing that led you to a different view?” Distinguish an incorrect fact from a different preference.

They give a long list

“Which one change would make the biggest difference for the next presentation?” A priority helps you act without pretending all changes are equally urgent.

Use one piece of feedback, then check it

Summarize the change in your own words and ask whether you understood. After trying it, assess the result and ask for another observation. Feedback is more useful when connected to a task than when saved as a vague judgment about your ability.

Keep praise as well as criticism if it tells you what to repeat. If feedback becomes insulting or discriminatory, you do not need to treat that as a useful development exercise. Use a suitable workplace support route.

Rehearse it first

Practice asking for an example without arguing, then summarize one change you understood. A simulated manager cannot assess your actual work; use rehearsal for the wording of the request.

Pretake on iPhone lets you practice messages with AI and rewind to try different words. It is AI practice, not the real person; a simulated reply cannot tell you what they will think or say. Practice messages are never sent to them.

Try Pretake on iPhone

18+ · Free to start · In-app purchases · Prices and limits

Prefer a worksheet? Use the free conversation planner. Read how imported chat text is processed before bringing private context.